Just when are some South Africans going to grow up?

There’s only one person I dig less than a foreigner criticising South Africa. Actually, let’s start again. there are only two people I dig less than a foreigner criticising my country and those are a South African expat living overseas whingeing about South Africa and a South African living here in the most amazing country in the entire chuffing world but banging on about how bad things are and wishing he was in Perth. Or London. Or Vancouver. Or Chernobyl. Or anywhere in the world but in South Africa.

What is this all about? I, the first person in South Africa (even before President Jacob Zuma) to be medically diagnosed as “SA-positive”, cannot get my head around it. That might well be because I’m phenomenally stupid. Fair dos.

But I think there’s more to it. A lot more. A festering, rotting, stinking lot more. And this became clear when Dianne Russell, a Canadian now living in South Africa, wrote a “guest post” on this blog, giving \”10 Reasons Why A Vancouverite Would Rather Live In Cape Town\”.

Dianne was simply exercising her right to give her personal opinion about her experience. As she did when she exercised her right to join her South African boyfriend here in Cape Town. Her eyes, unlike those of many whining South Africans, were opened to the beauty of our beloved country. Not just the physical beauty of the landscape but the beauty of our fascinatingly diverse peoples, their friendliness, their openness, their warmth, their vitality.

The view from Dianne Russell's Cape Town apartment... what a lucky Canadian!

But clearly she had not chatted to that weird group of South Africans – mostly, in the words of that nincompoop Julius Malema, of a “white tendency” – who live frozen in fear behind their electric fences and only come out by day to make large amounts of money and to go to braais held by their similarly-minded friends.

There they will wolf down humungous amounts of steak and boerewors, sluk on brandy-and-Coke and Castle Lager and whinge incessantly about how terrible crime and corruption is, how this country has gone to the dogs and, maggies, have you checked how bad the potholes are on the road to the office? These South Africans stand around the braai rooted in their collective consciousness and abject fear, moaning and wishing they could go to live in a “civilised country”.

They mourn “the good old days” (read the apartheid era) when most of the national resources were handed to them (a small percentage of the population) on a plate and the vast majority of South Africans had to get by on the scraps thrown to them. Now that our new democracy is founded on sharing everything equally among everybody (and the government is struggling to do that and make ends meet), these “SA-negative” people dream of supping on the “milk and honey” which apparently abounds in other countries.

Yeah, yeah. Pull the other one. When are these previously over-privileged South Africans going to grow up? Get real, mense. Have you even travelled abroad to grasp at the reality of living in stultifyingly over-regulated, overly politically correct and plain boring countries such as the United States, Britain, Canada, Australia and New Zealand? Please do. and make it a one-way ticket. You’re holding us back, bru. And your negativity is draining the beautiful energy the rest of us are putting out.

And some of you had the ignorance to write into this blog to bash away at the positivity Dianne Russell, a Canadian, feels about South Africa. Your anger was tangible, so much so that a rather confusedĀ Canadian blogger has brought it to the attention of Canada. How dare a foreigner move to our country and have the audacity to tell us how wonderful it all is? Who does she think she is? A South African? Ja, if she were South African she would share our pain at the moerse potholes our double cabs disappear into on a daily basis. And to be truly South African like us, she must give up her Canadian passport, hand in her Canadian dollars, stop being a “party girl” and sitting around sipping cocktails outside Caprice in Camps Bay and come to stand around our braai in Hierdieplekisblerriekakfontein and endlessly bemoan the increasing girth of Julius Malema and potholes.

Eish! But there is hope for these people. Remember Brandon Huntley, that sad South African okey who claimed political asylum in Canada after telling some gullible immigration officials there that he had been mugged, assaulted, sodomised and even sworn at at least five times a day while living in Mowbray, Cape Town. You do? Well, there you go. I’m sure there are quite a few countries that will give you full citizenship on the grounds that those potholes are getting so bloody big that you can’t get your double cab around them on your way to work. Then you can freeze happily ever after and leave us to somehow struggle on in the brilliant sunshine of our South African lives.

And I tell you what. Before you go, I’ll let you in on something personal. Back in the day (yes, under apartheid rule), when I was mos a laaitie – and before PW Botha’s military taught me how to shoot a R1 rifle at the commie terrorists on “the border” and before Home Affairs confiscated my passport because I refused to work as a spy for them in London and before they tapped my phone when I joined the Anti-Apartheid Movement there and before they detained me and interrogated me at Jan Smuts Airport when I next came back to South Africa to visit my parents… yes, before all of that – I used to play soccer barefoot with my friends, white and black – on a golden field near a river running through Pietermaritzburg. Late into the night and by the light of nearby houses.

And the next day, we would go down to that river and feel our chests thump as we whooshed down that foofie-slide that Uncle George had fixed high on a tree. And then, slightly bruised and bleeding, we would slosh around in the river, worried about bumping into the much-fearedĀ legavaan (Varanus abigularis or Monitor Lizard) that apparently could break a child’s leg with a swish of its tail.

A Legavaan... this mythical river beast could apparently break our legs with one swish of its tail

Then we would collect tadpoles in the river to take home to watch grow into frogs, stopping only to munch mulberries off a number of trees and grab a few leaves to feed the shoeboxes of hungry silkworms about to go through their cocoon-moth-egg-silkworm cycle. And once, when the river came down in flood, the boy next-door and I borrowed my mom’s zinc bath (used to bath the dogs) and sailed merrily down the river. We ended up about eight kilometres away, on the other side of Maritzburg, and I had to borrow five cents to phone my mom and ask her to come in the car to pick us up as we couldn’t carry the zinc bath all the way back.

It was a beautiful childhood. Until I became gradually aware of the racist policies of the government of the day. I owe a great debt to my country. South Africa owes me nothing. I love South Africa.

No more so than when I see, around where I am blessed to live, children of all tones of skin kicking a football around on the village green. And getting very animated when they spot the seal that has taken up residence in the river that runs through Stanford. These children won’t grow up to be told to shoot rifles in a crazy war, they won’t be asked to spy for a crazy government and it is highly unlikely that they will be stopped at OR Tambo Airport and interrogated about why they belong to an organisation that campaigns against a racist South Africa.

That, my friends, is why I believe that we live in a far better South Africa. A South Africa that is not without great challenges, for sure, but a South Africa in which I choose to live and die in. So, when you are around that braai this sunny weekend and the dop (liquor) is going down fast and freely – and perhaps you are watching the Bulls play Super 14 rugby in Soweto, nogal – please try to get your potholes drama into some perspective.

And, even better, perhaps you might want to clamber out of your huge pothole of fear, leave Dianne Russell alone, put on a Bafana Bafana jersey, get hold of a vuvuzela and join the rest of us “SA-positive” people in celebrating our uniquely wondrous country and the sensational World Cup we are about to host. Feel it. We SA-positives are here!

18 Comments

  1. Tweets that mention Just when are some South Africans going to grow up?| fred hatman -- Topsy.com
    May 21, 2010 @ 17:14:05

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Fred Hatman, Fred Hatman and mdp, Simon. Simon said: PRT @fredhatman Just when are some South Africans going to grow up? http://bit.ly/9DgrvW <– Wonderful stuff Fred. Really. [...]

  2. Crime Victim
    May 21, 2010 @ 18:05:46

    And when was the last time you had a gun in your face if the crime problem is an issue that your buddy Malema put it, that is only by the immature people of the “white tendency”? Ive been to SA, Ive been robbed. Sorry. Not fooling me buddy.

    I hope these people, people who dare look at things as they really are, black, white, Asian and coloured, instead of from the fantasy world you seem to be living in do come to the United States, we could use them.

    Im sure they’d be happy to escape a place that once had promise but is rapidly turning into a third world hell-hole with the rest of the continent. Its not a race issue, its a governance issue. And its amazing how you dont express an ounce of sympathy for the victims of crime or their families, most of whom aren’t white at all, but Black ANC voters who suffer from HIV and grinding poverty, while your beloved Malema and his boys cavort with the War criminal Mugabe (and im not talking about the Liberation War either, Im speaking of Gurukuahundi) and enrich themselves by seizing businesses they themselves did not have a hand in building.

    I bet you’d be singing another tune if the crooks took all of your money, your car, and raped your wife and children. I dont wish crime upon anyone, but you need to realize that it does happen.

    Cape Town doesnt have the highest violent crime rate in the world for no reason. Kabul, Kandahar, and Baghdad have lower incidences of violence, as does Juarez and Medellin. And whats really telling Afghanistan and Iraq are actually War Zones.

    You’re an eighth as likely to be killed in Iraq as you are in Cape Town. Sorry. Facts are facts. The UN, Interpol and FBI arent just making this stuff up.

    And what about the 3,000 dead farmer since 1994? I bet you’ll say they brought it upon themselves.

    And have you ever visited the United States? Ive visited South Africa, and I dont need your permission to speak about the problems I saw, however, if you haven’t visited the US, before you start talking nonsense, do yourself a favor and actually come here.

  3. Sipho
    May 21, 2010 @ 18:44:00

    Thank you, sir. Thank you, thank you, thank you.

  4. Susan
    May 21, 2010 @ 19:24:02

    Thank you!! I’m with you all the way!! 100%!! We can ignore “crime victim’s” tirade thereafter! If he believes in what the FBI says then he’ll believe anything! LOL!!

  5. Dianne Russell
    May 21, 2010 @ 19:43:20

    Me again. Seems like you have the usual audience front and centre in the first row!

    Thank you for doing what you do. It’s invaluable, and it’s infectious. People don’t realize how their personal energy spreads like a virus – if one doesn’t manage his/her negativity, it becomes epidemic, infecting everyone who is not grounded in peace. You, my cyber-friend (hope we get to meet one day so i can drop the cyber!) are like a negativity vaccination.

  6. dee
    May 21, 2010 @ 19:44:14

    Great Fred. Fantastic article. You’re a great writer. I love SA and you just reminded mw why again Regards

  7. Tim
    May 21, 2010 @ 19:53:34

    Hey Di (above),

    Just spent the past 15 minutes on your site – go girl!!

    Fred: Good post – and too true. I’d like to see the people behind their fences start looking around them, and seeing if they can do anything to improve the greater picture, rather than worry about whether they can upgrade from an X3 to an X5…

  8. Mathilde
    May 21, 2010 @ 22:37:28

    Born and bred in Paris – France I arrived in RSA by luck and immediately feel in love with the country and its people. That was 12 years ago. My love for this country grows every day as I see my children grow and learn so many languages, have so many divers friends, as I see the potholes bieng fixed (and yes I know there are still too many of them on the roads) as I see the enthousiam for the coming world cup, the friedliness of the people, the new train being built, the amazing wonders of the local nature,the stunning highveld weather, etc (the list is endless).
    Yes the crime is a major issue but it must not be the excuse to just watch and do nothing! I believe that in the past 12 years that I have been there, the country has improved tremendously. Administration is working much better, the road are being improved (yes I believe so), “things are starting to work!”.
    Bring your support to the government, help the process; don’t be passif and moan around your braai! Unless you do something for your country, you should not be allowed to moan about it.
    PS: As the saying goes: Rome wasn’t built over one night!

  9. Dianne Russell
    May 21, 2010 @ 23:13:27

    Hi Tim! Thanks for dropping by – come back and say hi anytime :-)

  10. Dianne Russell
    May 22, 2010 @ 08:47:30

    Hi Mathilde,

    Ahhh, Paris, another place that stole my heart many years ago…you have lived in a couple of amazing places!

    I really like what you said about not being allowed to moan if you don’t do anything to try to change the situation. It’s like anytime in life where that one guy always complains about everything – hate my job, hate my wife, hate my fat gut, hate my boredom…etc. I always want to just smack them on the head and say ‘stop complaining and start DOING!’

    It’s inspiring to know that you have been here so long and still feel the same way. People (the SA-negs) keep saying, ‘oh, you are just on a honeymoon with SA right now, it will all change, you’ll see…’. I think they are all waiting eagerly with grins on their faces, hoping I get mugged and suddenly start writing about how terrible it is there – a victory of sorts for the SA-NEGS. Well, they’ll be waiting till their hair falls out, their boobs sag and turn into ‘socks with rocks’, and their diapers (nappies in SA-speak) need to be changed 10 times a day.

    Cheers!
    :-D

  11. Robin Opperman
    May 22, 2010 @ 09:05:07

    I lived in Zimbabwe for five years, and I saw the same things said to people who spoke out. I am not one for being negative, and I agree when people from abroad criticize for no good reason it is infuriating. I do however feel that if we are convinced that our country is so great, it is our responsibility and our right to speak out when we feel something is wrong. There is a clear distinction between negative racist stereotyping, and proud South Africans who pay their taxes, live their lives here, and who feel the need to, and who have every right to speak out. Our Govt have a lot to answer for. They have proven their inability to deliver and govern effectively in many cases, and at this junction if we do not acknowledge that we are proud South Africans, but that the responsibility and rights that go with that, involve that we can and should speak out, then we are truly in trouble. Zimbabweans smiled sweetly, and the monster in the closet grew and grew. There are many good things here, and if we do not speak out, we will lose them. We have grown up, and part of that is speaking out in a non-racial and democratic way against any injustice and mismanagement that we see.

  12. Neal Collins
    May 22, 2010 @ 10:23:30

    Okay Donaldson, this is an award winner. Brilliantly written, evocative of all our childhoods. Apartheid nearly robbed us of a decent life, where every white with a South African accent would have been shunned all over the world. Instead, just in time, we slipped through the gap in the fence to create a brave new nation.
    Yes, as your first respondent says so forcefully, there are problems. I confront people like him every day after writing a few controversial pieces in the Mercury this week (they really didn’t like the headline yesterday: “Bloodbath in South Africa? It could happen in London”.
    The suggestion that we have no sympathy for victims of crime because we are “SA positive” is ridiculous. You go Howard. You remind these people what South Africa was REALLY like before 1994. How people would look at you in London back in those days. Like you were a Nazi. How if you dared to speak out, your phone started ringing in the middle of the night. And people, hundreds of them, simply disappeared.
    You want to go back to those days? I certainly don’t. Keep writing Howard. The World Cup will be a glittering stage for South Africa, and while recession grips Europe, South Africa (like Brazil and India) may just become a jewel in the crown.

  13. Bren
    May 22, 2010 @ 20:50:53

    Excellent!

  14. bongi
    May 22, 2010 @ 22:55:52

    i too am south africa positive. i love my country and will never leave. yet i see it differently to you. reading your post i think you would classify me as unpatriotic or something. i don’t think i fit into your cut way of seeing things and therefore i’m sure i fit into your catagory of get out of the country.

    you see even though i love my country i feel it my patriotic duty to critisize the government. i do not want to excuse them because they are so called trying harder than the previous regime (which was illegitimate and therefore shouldn’t even be brought into the equation) or for whatever reason. unlike them i do not believe in a one party state and until malema actually comes to power and puts a gag on me i will rant against the ruling party. i like braais and i do not like potholes. i realise in your eyes this makes me less south african than you but in the end that is your opinion and you are still welcome to it (until malema decrees otherwise).

  15. karen
    May 23, 2010 @ 05:36:18

    First I watched the Nedbank Cup Final at Soccer City – the opening of the stadium – vibesville Hatman, wish we were there!
    And it was quite a treat to see the Bulls playing rugby at Orlando Stadium, just down the road from Soccer cCty in Soweto – rugby with vuvuzelas is awesome! I noticed many Bulls fans with blue vuvus blowing lustily. (Vuvuzelas are banned in rugby stadiums).

  16. Louis de Villiers
    Jun 06, 2010 @ 18:02:12

    Thank you man, I criticize the failings of our government happily, but love living in my country. I have seen mos of the rest of the world.
    The rants about \guns in the face of your partner\ – if, indeed, you experienced it and aren’t complaining at tenth hand about somebody else’s trauma – misses the point.
    Of course any victim of crime deserves our sympathy, but I was almost relieved to be mugged so I can say: ja, I was mugged, but it didn’t turn me into a racist poephol.
    Cumbria in the UK didn’t become a rathole because some taxi-driver flipped his lid and even in New Zealand people have had guns in their faces.
    As for the token Zimbabwean bitching – I don’t see people in SA behaving at all like they did there. We moan here and we bitch; only problem comes in when we do nothing besides.
    Governments stink everywhere, Boet, and if you don’t believe me, go see for yourself.

  17. Persona non grata
    Jun 07, 2010 @ 00:01:33

    Nice one boet. Enjoyed that. SA deserves more people to be SA positive, particularly the perpetrators of crime.

  18. an sa guy
    Oct 10, 2010 @ 13:38:01

    So here we go….
    I am (well I have just as much right as anyone to say it !) a South African male (yes sorry white)…41 now.. born 1969 1
    I have grown up through all the shit , the worst times I guess.
    I was born in Johannesburg then we moved to Rustenburg (out in the country because my dad serviced pertrol garages in the North and West of the country.
    He used to travel like crazy, worked himself to the bone in fact to keep mom and us kids (3 of us) looked after), we weren’t rich and certainly never led a charmed life at all !
    Of the early years I remember spedning a lot of time in the bush and enjoying a really carefree and fun childhood.
    We moved back to Johannesburg when I was five years old. We spent what must have been a month in a hotel in Hillbrow. After the month my folks had managed to find a flat to live in (both of them had grown up in Johannesburg and had met eachother there and ended up getting married there too !
    Yes dad had gone to battle in El Alamein since we (South Africa) were allies in those times. (More about that some other time I guess!)
    Anyways as the story goes we settled into a flat in Hillbrow. In 1987 my dad died and mom and I continued to stay there while I studied.
    Crime was increasing in Hillbrow and more and more bad folks were moving in.
    In 1989 I finally managed to get my mom and myslef out and we moved to Johannesburg North wherelife was a little less crime ridden (we thought)
    I was called up to the army to do my national service ( never understood why really , and no one had ever explained why I had to go and learn to be a soldier nor fight for a war or something I had no idea about!) I hated the very idea of it but apparently South Africa was under threat by communist countries along the lines of Russia and so forth and we were supposed to protect against being taken over.
    I do remember that in those years the ANC were the ‘terrorists’ since they were the party that were bombing areas in South Africa.
    I will always remember that wherever we went we would be concious of a possible bomb threat and would have to be ready to move at the drop of a hat.
    The threat was very real and I remember several huge explosions occuring near me in the years when I was growing up. I remember specifically a bomb going off in Ellis Park which was mere few kilometers from the area we lived in. It was for this reason that we tended to avoid large public gatherings and the likes of !

    So what do you feel about that Mr Fredhatman ?
    Any thoughts?

    And now let me tell you about life in Hillbrow, were on any niht I could look out our flat window and see cars and car radios being stolen by black guys at random times (yes only black guys) . I personally had my car and car sradios stolen many a time …do you think I ever got them back ?
    Just recently I had my car stolen from a drive through burger place ..in broad daylight.

    Don’t worry though ‘cos the guys who stole it can have it .. I mena they didn’t work for it ..did they ? And even if they did ..what right to they have to it …? Well let me tell you something …they have every right to take it , it is theirs!
    Because in South Africa yo uare welcome to take whatever you like and there is no penalty ..in fact even if there is a penalty, the time spent in prison is far better than having to live in a shack your whole life right ? You are looked after.
    Over in South Africa you can be on pop idols if you are an ex con not so ?
    You can even be a presisdent if you commit the right crimes. ]
    See there is no repercussion if you commit the crime.
    Nothing I accumulate here in this country ( nor that which my folks accumulated or achieved) will ever be mine …not so ?
    Because any old cockraoch off the street can have it. Did you say youth league member?

    Yes I live in South Africa , I have travelled the world and seen many a place and culture, sadly I have yet to find a country and place which is just like South Africa, but man oh man I am so disillusioned almost at the verge of tears every day of my life.
    I have no more history here, no roots anymore. The battle of blood river didn’t even happen and the places I grew up to know and learned about have had there names changed to names I have no idea about or could even bother to rememeber or understand.
    I am a legal alien.
    In a country where the in order to get some sort of status I should commit a crime , the bigger the crime the better and make sure it’s in front of enough people and it must be public too.
    So how many potential Lee Harvey Oswalds do we have here ?
    Is this not the time to appeal to the youth of today ( those who are about to commit suicide) and say .. “Hey don’t you want to be famous ?” “All you have to do is off some prominent public figure and whammo you can start a revolution or be listed in every hostory book on the planet .. ” So easily my friend so easily.

    And Mr Fredhatman are living in a capsule, and you will completely understand it when a haenous crime happens to you (gee in fact I bet you haven’t even had a petty SA crime happen to you right ?)
    You my man will change you attitude as quickly as you got an attitude adjusting klap when you were in the army ..but worse!

    Surely you must have ‘friends’ who have been atacked, robbed,raped,stabbed, killed, hi-jacked or anything else happen to them ?
    Do you just say ‘Ag well it wasn’t m bru! I’m ok jack and bugger you! Dankie vok dit was nie ekke nie ‘

    Did you read about the girl who got hi-jacked and then flung of a bridge into a river n Durban and was just left to die ?
    Could have been you buddy !
    Haha in fact I would love it if it di happen to you ..can’t wait to read your story. It will probably go something like…”Lying here in my hospital bed…” , well of course that is assuming they actually let you live or you manage to escape !

    I have a lady friend whose folks were hi-jacked in the driveway to their house. her dad was shot so badly that he couldn’t work for 5 years (he was 5 years away from retirement) and she and her husband had to move n with them to look after them.
    The entire family is scarred for life and still traumatised
    You are either totally stoned everyday of your life or live a very charemed life in your little Cape Town Bubble.
    WAKE UP !
    I see you have the intelligence to at least knock up your thoughts on an internet blog but surely you can’t be missing the headline news and radio reports about the crime ?
    DUDE come on ! Seriously …!
    You really are living in a BUBBLE …

    If we emigrate to America what are we to become ?
    African Americans of course !
    But wait a sec , aren’t African Americans black ?
    Mmmm
    And over in South Africa we are BOERS or SETTLERS not so ?
    And wait a second. there are people dancing for us … what’s ithat they are chanting as they dance ? they look so happy .. what are they singing ?
    “One settler, one bullet” Africa for the Africans.

    Anyways Mr Fredhatman .. all the best in ‘our’ country … I will always be your china wherever you are in the world bru ‘cos “South Africans” stick together don’t they ?

    As they say i nAfrikaans …Maak oop jou oe !
    Sin jy ‘n blinde derempie ?

Leave a Reply